The Research Forum on Outcomes in Cross-Sector Collaboration is a gathering of researchers whose work engages with, or relates to, outcomes-based approaches to public service provision. Every two months, the Forum hosts guest speakers to present an aspect of their research or talk through a particular issue that is influencing their work. The research forum is co-hosted by the Government Outcomes Lab, University of Oxford, and The Center for Research on Public-Private Collaboration, Roskilde University.
Themes of interest to the Forum include:
We aim to reflect the full breadth that these topics entail, as well as issues relating to research process and methodology. We therefore welcome empirical content from different locations around the world, as well as theoretical discussions covering the various conceptual frameworks through which efforts to improve social outcomes can be interpreted and understood.
The sessions are intended to be informal in nature, allowing for free-flowing discussion, the testing of ideas among peers, and wrestling with the challenges of interdisciplinary work in this space. The Research Forum therefore provides an arena for researchers away from the demands of having a polished ‘policy message’ or published paper. In doing so, we hope to develop a scholarly network that will enrich our research, disseminate ideas, and foster collaboration across institutions.
Research Forum meetings are one hour and 15 minutes long, and are held online. They are free to attend, and anyone who is interested is welcome to join. The target audience is principally researchers, however, and these sessions will particularly appeal to members of academic institutions, consultancies, and/or think tanks, whose work relates to the above outlined themes.
If you are interested in presenting at the Forum please contact Eleanor Carter, Research Director at the Government Outcomes Lab, or Ole Helby Petersen, Director of The Center for Research on Public-Private Collaboration, Roskilde University.
The Research Forum is going on holiday for the summer! We will reconvene again in the autumn. A big thanks to everyone who has joined the sessions so far - we look forward to seeing you again soon.
Efficiency and value-for-money are key goals for governments outsourcing goods and services. Contracting with external agents is often justified in these terms. It is also observed that procurement contracts can be difficult to deliver, and, when they go wrong, can instead cause value loss. In this Research Forum session, we explored the motives and consequences of contract cancellations and renegotiations. Professors Lena Brogaard and Fernando Domingos presented their latest research and analysis on these two topics respectively. Professor Deanna Malatesta acted as the discussant, offering reflections on the papers presented, and initiating contributions and questions from the audience. We discussed explanatory factors of cancellation and renegotiation, and considered how procurement policy can respond to them.
Public sector contracting can contribute to a variety of public values. Government set-aside programs for small and disadvantaged businesses are intended to increase diversity and equity in public sector contracting. In this seminar we were joined by professors Benjamin M. Brunjes, Evelyn Rodriguez-Plesa, and Matthew Potoski to discuss experiences with small and disadvantaged business set-aside programs. Drawing on experiences with these programs at the federal, state, and local level in the United States, the seminar focused both on the broader picture – what purposes these programs serve in promoting broader public values in cross-sector contracting – and recent experiences from empirical studies of set-aside programs. We discussed the successes, challenges, and lessons learned from these programs, and their implications for policy.
Hilary Olson is a doctoral candidate at the Price School of Public Policy, University of Southern California, where she researches social innovation and program evaluation. For our first Research Forum of 2023, Hilary presented a forthcoming paper from her PhD. Drawing on interviews, user data, and document analysis, the presentation examined the potential for social impact bonds to contribute to systems change.
For the November session of the Research Forum we were joined by Kuno Schedler, Professor of Management at the University of St. Gallen, Switzerland. Professor Schedler presented some of his most recent work on different models for service provision in the public sector. He described how he classified 45 different public sector service models, and 5 distinct roles the government plays within these models. Together, these make up the 'Service Model Navigator' - a tool that can help guide practitioners towards innovative solutions for task performance in specific situations.
As ever, there was plenty of time for participants to discuss the presentation and ask questions.
Date: 22 September 2022
For this special edition of the Government Outcomes Lab Research Forum, we were joined by Professor Sandro Cabral, Insper Institute of Education and Research. Professor Cabral presented his recent paper, 'Can public organizations perform as private firms? The role of heterogeneous resources and practices'. Focusing on the Brazilian education sector, he compared the organizational traits of public and private schools, and used data to explore some explanations for differences in their performance.
Note: we broke from our usual Friday time-slot for this event, to coincide with Professor Cabral's visit to the Government Outcomes Lab, where he presented in person.
Date: 24 June 2022
For our third Research Forum meeting we were joined by Professor Giulio Pasi. Giulio is a Scientific Officer and Policy Advisor at the European Commission, and Associate Professor at Loyola University Andalusia. He presented some aspects of his current research agenda, which considers reasons behind the rapid spread of Impact Bonds across different political and institutional contexts. Participants had the chance to respond to and question Professor Pasi about this work, particularly regarding his methodological approach.
Date: 29 April 2022
Fernando is a Postdoctoral Research Associate at the GO Lab. For our Research Forum, he presented data from the team’s ongoing research into the ‘inner workings’ of a Social Impact Bond (SIB) – that is, whether and how SIBs may foster effective collaboration in services. Focusing on the Kirklees Life Chances Fund SIB, the research pursues longitudinal analysis of a number of organisations as their contracting arrangements shift from bilateral fee-for-service to the adoption of a SIB. In sum, the research investigates what is involved in establishing effective collaboration, and how stakeholders perceive the changes brought about by the introduction of a SIB contracting arrangement.
Date: 25 February 2022
For the inaugural Government Outcomes Lab Research Forum, we were joined by Carolyn Heinrich, Hart Professor of Public Policy and Education at Vanderbilt University. Prof Heinrich Professor Heinrich led us in a discussion titled: From formal vs. relational to formal relational? Contemplating the future of public sector contracting.